The Orphan Trains: 200,000 Children Sent West to Find a Home

Three homeless boys asleep over a steam grate on Mulberry Street, New York, photographed by Jacob Riis around 1890

Three homeless boys asleep over a steam grate on Mulberry Street in New York, photographed by Jacob Riis around 1890 — public domain via Wikimedia Commons.

In the 1850s, New York City had a problem it could not hide. Thousands of children — dirty and ragged — slept in doorways and over the warm steam grates of the streets. They sold matches, rags, and newspapers to survive, and banded together in gangs for protection. An estimated 10,000 to 30,000 children were homeless in New York, a city of only about 500,000 people.

Between 1854 and 1929, about 200,000 of those children were put on trains and sent west to new families — the largest child migration in American history, and one of the most forgotten. It was called “placing out,” and the trains became known as the orphan trains. The idea behind them was simple: a child would do better with a farm family in the open country than on the streets of a crowded city. What actually happened to the children was far more complicated — and far more human — than the plan.

The children of the streets

New York in the 1850s was a city overwhelmed by immigration. Families arrived from Ireland and Germany and found hardship instead of opportunity. Epidemics of typhoid and yellow fever killed parents; poverty, illness, and addiction broke other families apart. The children left behind had almost nowhere to go: orphanages existed, but their capacity fell far short of the need, and the police called the street children “street Arabs” and “street rats.”

The man who decided to do something about it was Charles Loring Brace, a 27-year-old Congregational minister. Born in Litchfield, Connecticut, in 1826 and educated at Yale and Union Theological Seminary, Brace had come to New York to preach to the poor of Blackwell’s Island and the Five Points slum. In 1853 he founded the Children’s Aid Society, and the next year he opened the Newsboys’ Lodging House, the country’s first shelter for runaway boys.

Brace did not believe in orphanages. He thought institutions fed children and handed them charity, and in doing so only deepened their dependence. A family, he believed, was the answer. “In every American community, especially in a western one, there are many spare places at the table of life,” he wrote. The expanding farm country of the Midwest needed workers, and Brace believed farmers would welcome homeless children and raise them as their own. After a year of sending children one by one to farms in Connecticut, Pennsylvania, and rural New York, his society tried something bigger.

The first train west

On September 20, 1854, a party of 46 children — most of them between ten and twelve years old — left New York under the care of a Children’s Aid Society agent named E. P. Smith, bound for Dowagiac, Michigan. They arrived on October 1, and within five days most of the 46 had found homes. The expedition was judged such a success that in January 1855 the society sent two more parties west, to Pennsylvania.

The trains kept coming. The Children’s Aid Society sent an average of about 3,000 children a year between 1855 and 1875, and over the next 75 years the movement placed children in 45 states, as well as in Canada and Mexico. Indiana received the largest number in the early years, and about 7,000 children were placed in Kansas alone.

How a child was chosen

Before a train was due, the placing agents sent word ahead. Notices headed “Homes Wanted for Orphans” appeared in local newspapers, and committees of prominent local citizens arranged a hall — an opera house, a town hall, or a church — for the presentation. A 1910 flyer for Troy, Missouri, announced that “a company of homeless children from the East will arrive at Troy, Mo., on Friday, Feb. 25th, 1910,” and invited the town to “come and see the children and hear the address.”

A 1910 flyer announcing the arrival of orphan train children in Troy, Missouri

A 1910 flyer announcing the arrival of orphan train children in Troy, Missouri — from the Troy Free Press, February 11, 1910, public domain via Wikimedia Commons.

When the train arrived, the children were lined up on a stage, where they took turns giving their names, singing a little song, or “saying a piece” — while prospective parents inspected them, sometimes prodding them and checking how many teeth they had. Siblings who had travelled together were frequently separated, because a family could choose to take a single child. The practice is often credited with giving English the phrase “up for adoption.”

The terms, on paper, were strict. Families were expected to treat the children as their own, providing decent food, clothing, and schooling, and to give each child $100 at twenty-one. In reality there were only a handful of agents to monitor thousands of placements, and the screening of families was left largely to local volunteer committees — who were often reluctant to reject a neighbour as unfit.

The baby trains

The Children’s Aid Society was not the only organisation sending children west. In 1869, Sister Mary Irene Fitzgibbon of the Sisters of Charity founded the New York Foundling Hospital as a shelter for abandoned infants. From 1875 to 1914, it sent infants and toddlers to prearranged Catholic homes across the Midwest and South — first called the “baby trains,” then the “mercy trains.” All told, the Foundling Hospital sent some 54,000 children west, while the Children’s Aid Society sent about 150,000.

The other side of the story

For all its good intentions, the orphan train movement has always had a second story, and it deserves to be told honestly. First, the name was misleading: less than half of the children who rode the trains were actually orphans, and as many as one in four had two living parents. Children ended up on the trains because their families were too poor to raise them, because they had been abused or abandoned, or because they had run away.

Second, the oversight was thin. An independent investigation in 1883 found that local committees were ineffective at screening foster parents and supervision was lax, though its overall conclusion was still positive: most children under fourteen were leading satisfactory lives. Catholic clergy charged that the Protestant-led Children’s Aid Society was using placing out to convert poor Catholic children.

The worst single episode came in 1904, when the Foundling Hospital sent 40 white children, aged between eighteen months and five years, to Catholic families in an Arizona Territory parish. The families approved by the local priest were Mexican-American, and a group of white men seized the children and placed most of them with Anglo families instead. The courts declined to return them.

Not every rider’s story was a sad one, and the riders themselves said so. Stanley Cornell, who rode an orphan train in 1925 after his mother’s death, told CNN in 2008: “We’d pull into a train station, stand outside the coaches dressed in our best clothes. People would inspect us like cattle farmers. And if they didn’t choose you, you’d get back on the train and do it all over again at the next stop.” A 1910 survey by the Children’s Aid Society found that 87 percent of the children sent to country homes had “done well.”

The end of the line

By the 1920s, the world that had made the orphan trains possible was disappearing. The West was settled, and the demand for adoptable children fell. In 1895, Michigan passed a law requiring a bond before out-of-state children could be placed there; other states soon passed similar laws. In 1909, the first White House Conference on Dependent Children praised the Children’s Aid Society’s work but argued that children should be kept with their own families where possible, or placed with a foster family nearby. The United States Children’s Bureau, founded in 1912, pushed the same idea: support the family, rather than remove the child.

The agreements that had allowed the trains to keep running expired in 1929 and were not renewed, and the last orphan train ran that year, seventy-five years after the first.

What the orphan trains left behind

The orphan trains ended, but the idea behind them did not. Brace’s belief that children are better cared for by families than in institutions is the basic principle of the modern foster care system, and the placing-out system is widely regarded as its direct forerunner. Some riders went on to prominent lives: Andrew H. Burke became governor of North Dakota, and John Green Brady became governor of Alaska.

Today, the story is kept alive in Concordia, Kansas, where the National Orphan Train Complex — a museum and research centre in the restored 1917 Union Pacific depot — holds files on more than 6,000 riders, along with their photographs, letters, and belongings. The Complex estimates that as many as one in twelve Americans may be connected to an orphan train rider. Like the Peshtigo Fire, another American story that nearly vanished, the orphan trains were almost lost to history. For most of the twentieth century, the riders rarely spoke about what had happened to them. It is a story of charity and of harm, of rescue and of loss, and it belongs to far more American families than most of them know.

References

Fact notes: The total is given as “about 200,000” — the most widely cited figure — but estimates range as high as 250,000. Sources differ slightly on the first party (46 children left New York on September 20, 1854; 45 are recorded as arriving in Dowagiac on October 1), so only the departure figure is stated. The claim that the stage presentations gave English the phrase “up for adoption” is presented as a widely repeated claim, not a settled fact. The last train’s destination differs between sources, so only the year, 1929, is stated. The 1910 survey figure (87%) is the Children’s Aid Society’s own number.

Comments